Consequences of the Demographic Change for the Swiss Labour Market

Ref. 13890

General description

Period

2015-2080

Geographical Area

Additional Geographical Information​

Schweiz

Abstract

According to the most recent population forecasts for Switzerland (Bundesamt für Statistik 2015), the share of old-age dependants (older than 65 years) relative to the working age population (20-64) is going to increase from 29.1% in 2015 to 48.1% in 2045. In the same time span, total population is expected to grow from 8.3 million to 10.2 million while the potential workforce is growing from 4.8 million to 5.3 million. As a result, potential labour supply per capita is decreasing and at the same time the share of old-age dependants as well as the average age of the population are increasing rapidly. Among other problems, this is going to lead to significant distortions on labour markets; such as labour shortages or shifts in the structure of labour demand due to shifts in final goods demand. Furthermore, the current political climate in Switzerland tends towards restricting immigration. Since the Swiss economy already relies heavily on foreign workers, a restriction of immigration might aggravate the predicted labour supply shortages even further. The goal of this research project is to evaluate the consequences of population ageing for the Swiss labour market. A special focus lies on the labour demand side, specifically on medium and long term sectoral and occupational shifts caused by a decrease in (skilled) labour supply and a change in consumer demand structure due to the demographic change. Moreover, the general equilibrium effects of different policy reforms will be evaluated and compared. To achieve this goal we construct a dynamic overlapping generations (OLG) computable general equilibrium (CGE) model of Switzerland and calibrate it with current Swiss data. Models of this type are the conventional approach to evaluating inter- and intra-generational effects of population ageing. However, only few studies focus on the labour market and even fewer emphasise the demand side. The evidence is particularly scarce for Switzerland, where only a handful of general equilibrium analyses relating to population ageing have been conducted. In order to facilitate estimating realistic parameters of the model as well as calibrating the model to expected short and medium term industry-specific developments we conduct a customised firm level survey, which, on its own, already constitutes a significant contribution to the relevant literature. The finalised model does not only allow us to predict transitional and long-term effects of the demographic change on the economy and the industry structure. It also provides us with the ability to evaluate and compare different reform proposals, such as an increase in the retirement age, reforms of the pension and healthcare systems and different immigration scenarios. As such, we will be able to give recommendations for optimal policy choice and provide valuable inputs to the political debate.

Results

The results show the drastic effects of demographic change in the form of four major effects. First, simulated GDP per capita grows until 2030 but then starts declining until the end of the model horizon. Second, contribution rates to the pension system would have to almost double until 2080 to keep the pension sustainable. Third, due to changes in the age distribution of the population, consumption and investment demand shifts away from construction and towards the health sector. Fourth, the model predicts massive wage rate increases in particular for young workers in service-oriented sectors. Due to the stickiness of wages, this effect will most likely lead to labor shortages in most sectors, but especially in the health sector. While the retirement age increase as well as the participation rate increase reforms both have very similar macroeconomic outcomes, they affect the labor market in very different ways, in particular in terms of labor shortages. Participation rate increases manage to reduce shortages to some degree, whereas the retirement age increase exacerbates the issue even more. The project also compares the economic outcomes of the demographic transition using a range of scenarios of the Swiss Statistical Office with respect to migration and fertility. This comparison reveals that even moderate changes in assumptions concerning migration will change labor market forecasts significantly. However, none of the evaluated reforms manages to offset the labor market effects of demographic change completely.